Daily Reflections

by bob k.

January 11 The spirituality of imperfection begins with the recognition that trying to be perfect is the most tragic human mistake.
The Spirituality of Imperfection, Kurtz & Ketcham, p. 5

The authors elaborate on this idea and, in doing so, get to the core of Alcoholics Anonymous. “In direct contradiction of the serpent’s promise in Eden’s Garden, the book Alcoholics Anonymous suggests, ‘First of all, we had to quit playing God.’ According to the way of life that flows from this insight, it is only by ceasing to play God, by coming to terms with errors and shortcomings, and by accepting the inability to control every aspect of their lives that alcoholics (or any human beings) can find the peace and serenity that alcohol (or other drugs, or sex, money, material possessions, power, or privilege) promise but never deliver.” (Kurtz & Ketcham, p. 5)

The American Dream offers false promises. Bill Wilson developed low self-esteem as the result of a trying childhood. He thought that money, material possessions, power and privilege would bring the admiration of his fellows, prestige, and an elevated sense of self-worth. Years earlier, some such feelings had come when his kindly maternal grandfather had made a huge fuss about his successful construction of a boomerang. “You’re a Number One man!”

Here was the key—accomplishment.

Determination and persistence would bring achievement and happiness would follow. In the adult world, that didn’t prove to be true and Wilson numbed himself with increasing quantities of alcohol, even during his period of material success. His “life formula” was flawed. He sought admiration but instead was seen as a drunken, loutish braggart.

When you had success, was it disappointing? Is 12-step spirituality more appealing than religion? Is it a fruitless mission to seek to control things falling outside of a very small range? Were you attracted to the openness of your peers in recovery regarding their imperfection?

January 12 Happiness and freedom begin with a clear understanding of one principle. Some things are within your control. And some things are not.
Epictetus, d. 145 A.D.

God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change;
Courage to change the things I can;
And wisdom to know the difference.

If only it were that easy—trillions of life mistakes would be poofed away!

At least the prayer is calling attention to something a tremendous number of people seem unconscious of as they go about their daily business of telling others how to fix their daily business. The wisdom of 19 centuries ago applies to-day. Each individual has a very limited locus of control. Very limited. The genius of my insights aside, people are little interested in my plans for their lives. They fail to comply and I am hurt.

What is wrong with these people?

We can become so busy with our plans for others—spouses, children, bosses, coworkers, neighbors, in-laws and legislators—that we neglect to change the things we can. Epictetus also mentions freedom. We can become chained to our machinations for improving the lives of other people. Our motives are so pure that it is difficult to recognize that we have embarked on an ill-fated venture.

Let’s move forward with more attention paid to the wisdom of Epictetus and Reverend Niebuhr.

Am I something of a control freak? Do I have great ideas for what other folks should be doing? Am I disappointed when my loving direction is ignored? How important is it that someone might load the dishwasher imperfectly?

January 13 EVERYDAY HABITS THAT DRAIN OUR ENERGY

1. Taking things too personally
2. Taking things too personally
3. Taking things too personally
4. Over-stressing
5. Sleeping in late
6. Fueling drama
7. Having a poor diet
8. Complaining all the time
9. Overthinking
10. Gossiping
11. Not living in the moment
12. Trying to please others

This is a list of classic mistakes. If one examines 5,000 inspirational quotes, there aren’t 5,000 different pieces of advice. A relatively small number of kernels of wisdom appear again and again. Following the triple warning against taking things too personally, the list moves to a huge one for the excessively anxious! Sleeping late can be an effort to hide from the world. Over-stressing, fuelling drama and constantly complaining aren’t big issues for me. We’re all a bit different. Overthinking, not living in the moment and trying to please others are failings for me. I’m not big on gossiping, but I can fall into it.

There are some physical elements on the list. In modern recovery, there’s a lot of talk about caring for the body. I could be better regarding diet and exercise and I like sleeping in. In my experience, when I want to make some positive changes, I do best focusing on one, two, or three zones of improvement and monitoring myself for progress in these areas. Perhaps I can try to get a friend to join in the challenge. That raises the level of commitment and the accountability from checking in regularly is beneficial.

What energy drainers jump out at you? Are you currently working on changing any? Can you add to the list?


The featured image at the top of this page can be found on this very new website, created by bob’s niece, Cynthia: https://bobk.ca/.

And this is the biography she included:

So far, two books by bob have been published. You can click on either one for more details.Bob k has been a sober and active member of Alcoholics Anonymous since October 28, 1991. He is the son of an alcoholic who was the son of an alcoholic. Bob qualifies for Al Alon and Adult Children of Alcoholics and has been to meetings of those two societies. He has also visited Narcotics Anonymous, Cocaine Anonymous, and Food Addicts in Recovery.

From 2004-2006, Bob supplied articles on AA’s “Big Book” to Toronto Intergroup’s newsletter, Better Times.

He has been a regular contributor to the websites AAAgnostic.org and AA Beyond Belief. Many of those essays were on the subject of AA history. In 2015, Bob published Key Players in AA History.

A second, expanded edition of that volume was released in 2023 as was The Secret Diaries of Bill W., a fictional look at AA’s founder. Bob has made presentations at AA history meetings and at conferences.

Coming soon is Almost Hopeless : Pre-AA Efforts to Reform America’s Alcoholics.

Bob worked in sales for many years before a dramatic career change in 1990 to teaching golf. He was a respected member of the PGA of Canada for many years and had some successes, provincially and nationally, as a player. Whitby, just east of Toronto, is home.


For a PDF of this article, click here: Daily Reflections.


 

5 Responses

  1. Ron G. says:

    Thank you for your continued support and encouragement and contribution!

  2. Joe C says:

    Thanks Bob,
    I find myself talking to you with questions and comments as I miander through your book – not out loud; not yet, anyway.

    Thanks Bob; I’m enjoying our conversations:-)

  3. John M. says:

    Great stuff, Bob. Always thought-provoking. Congratulations on the book launch.

  4. Richard Clark says:

    What are atheists up against? In “Spirituality of Imperfection,” Kurtz & Ketchum offer yet one more in a series of books that perpetuate recovery chaos and camouflage the abuses of theism. There’s no clarity to their double-speak. It sounds like: “I’m an atheist but let’s depend on Christianity and God’s words for wisdom.” There are poorly explained cliches, out of context bible quotes, and misleading innuendo about the nature of addiction. There are books and on-line articles by atheist-agnostics claiming insight and clarity that are held in such reverence that it’s unacceptable to question them. Similarly, fervent religious believers hold God and their doctrines in such reverence that to disagree is sacrilege. Atheists be advised: A University of BC study of American Christians several years ago found that 75-80% of American Christians believed that atheists were as trustworthy as pedophiles. What are we up against? There’s no hesitation in perpetuating what arguably might be the single most egregious error in addiction treatment—the repeated attempts to trivialize recovery into thirty days of religious cliches and ‘surrender.’ For those people trying to believe we are ill and not bad Christians: It is necessary to understand the dysfunctional, self-destructive relationship psychology that sits underneath addiction, just as the same relationship dysfunction exists in religion. Stable, long-term recovery requires, along with some version of wise counsel, the exclusion of cliches, pithy affirmations, confusion, and religious rhetoric. That’s what we are up against.

  5. Bill L. says:

    Alcoholics Anonymous Misquoting the Serenity Prayer
    by Nick Gromicko

    The Serenity Prayer is often misquoted.  For example,  Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) misstates it like this: 

    God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change,
    The courage to change the things I can,
    And wisdom to know the difference. 

    AA’s incorrect version makes no sense. 

    Why would you need serenity to accept only the things you cannot change?  Instead, wouldn’t you need serenity to accept everything that cannot be changed? Furthermore, God making you serene enough so that you’ll accept something isn’t really accepting it willingly.  He might as well just make you drunk enough to accept it.

    Instead, God might give you the grace to accept something calmly. That would be a more reasonable request of God. And it would put the burden on you to keep your head.

    Also, changing things just for the sake of change isn’t necessarily good.  Hitler changed things.  He changed peace into horror. Instead, wouldn’t you rather change the things you should change?  Furthermore, if you already can change something that needs to be changed, do you really need to pray for the courage to?  Just do it!  A slave owner in the 1800s didn’t need much courage to free his slaves, but he’d need lots of courage to help end slavery. That would require some courage to pray for.  Changing just the things you can requires little courage.

    And, finally, do you really want God to give you the wisdom to instantly know the difference between the two without having to think about it?  I don’t think God is going to grant that wish.  That’s too easy and would allow you to blame Him for not having the wisdom.  You’re not a robot.  Instead, God might give you enough wisdom to use to distinguish one from the other.  “Giving wisdom to know” puts the burden on God to give you knowledge.  Conversely, having the wisdom to use as a tool “to distinguish” puts the burden on you, where it belongs, to figure it out.  The words “grant” and “distinguish” are verbs.  God does one and you do the other.  
    Beating addiction requires a partnership between you and God.  You aren’t alone, but you also can’t expect your partner to do all the work.

    The Serenity Prayer was written by Reinhold Niebuhr.  Karl Paul Reinhold Niebuhr was an American theologian, ethicist, intellectual, commentator on politics and public affairs, and professor at Union Theological Seminary for more than 30 years. 

    This is the original (true) Serenity Prayer:

    God, give me grace to accept with serenity
    the things that cannot be changed,
    Courage to change the things
    which should be changed,
    And the Wisdom to distinguish
    the one from the other.

    It was written by Dr. Reinhold Neibuhr of Union Theological Seminary who used it as the ending to a longer prayer in 1932.  It was included in the “Way of Light,” a manual of praise, prayers and meditations compiled by Robbins Howard Chandler.

    So where did AA’s version come from? Bill Wilson, co-founder of AA found the misquoted version in an obituary in the New York Herald Tribune and copied it word for word.  It has been misquoted by AA ever since.

    I suppose AA can call their misquoted prayer “The Serenity Prayer” if they want to. I suppose they can call it “The Gettysburg Address” too.  But it is neither.  The real Serenity Prayer has a totally different meaning.

    So, the next time you’re at an AA meeting, have the courage to change the things that should be changed, including AA’s misquote of the Serenity Prayer. 

    Wilson’s misquoted version is so deeply ingrained in the “Group Consciousness” of most AA meetings that it is not likely ever going to change.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Translate »

Discover more from AA Agnostica

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading