The Magical Mystery Tour

By Roger C.

There are many things over my lifetime that have led me to understand that life is indeed a Magical Mystery Tour.

My earliest memory is when I was nine years old. I remember being in my back yard with a somewhat older boy  and girl. He said to her: “You know a baby can be born in your belly, don’t you? And it will be in your belly for nine months.” She nodded. I hadn’t known that that is how humans were born. I was totally stunned. Later on I learned how women became pregnant. My reaction: that too to me is a mystery. Indeed. And I have always considered it a bizarre, and magical, mystery.

My mother was a very religious person. We went to church every Sunday. And I attended a Catholic school, and recited the Lord’s Prayer every morning. Finally, at the age of nineteen, I quit believing in a God. None of the God stuff made any sense to me. A God, a Heaven, a Hell and a Purgatory?

If I was a good enough person when I died, would I be in purgatory for years and years and in Heaven for an eternity? That made zero sense at all to me.

In order to better understand all of this I ended up getting a BA (Laurentian University) and an MA (McGill University) in Religious Studies. In all those years in the universities there was zero evidence of the existence of a God. So these days when I go for a walk why do I see so many churches? Makes no sense to me at all. It strikes me as a key ingredient of the insanity of humanity.

Around that time of my life, I began drinking a lot. I became an alcoholic. At the time it was the solution to the pollution of my life. I didn’t particularly like my life so I created the booze solution.

Well, of course, it made my life worse. Much worse. And this lasted until I was sixty.

Over that time I ruined two marriages and both ended in divorces. I had blackouts. I drove my car even when I was drunk. One day I got a DUI and my brother sent me to a rehab facility. I finally realized that drinking was absolutely ruining my life. I had to stop. And it is only when an alcoholic understands that he or she has to stop drinking that it will actually happen and his or her life will then be truly better. So, I quit drinking on March 8th, 2010 – some fourteen years ago.

At that time I started going to AA meetings. But, frankly, it turned out that I couldn’t stand them. There was too much God stuff. The Big Book – often a part of traditional AA meetings – refers to God (or Him, etc.) 281 times in its first 164 pages. And its 12 Steps refer to God six times. And how do most of these meetings end? Well, with the Lord’s Prayer. Not only that, I was told at these meetings that if I didn’t believe in a God I wouldn’t stay sober. Traditional meetings claim that they are not religious. The only proper and relevant answer to that: bullshit. Pushing the God on people and doing the Lord’s Prayer is religion.

At around that time, I was able to find a secular AA meeting launched by Joe C. (author of the book Beyond Belief) and I began going to it every Thursday and Saturday. It is called Beyond Belief Agnostics and Freethinkers. I loved the meeting. After attending it for only six months and being roughly one year sober, the meeting was booted out of AA in 2011. Why? Because we used a secular version of the 12 Steps! We were booted out by the Greater Toronto Area Intergroup (GTAI) because there was no God in our Steps. And it took six years until the GTAI was forced to allow our group back in to their list of Alcoholics Anonymous groups.

God! As a child I had had God pushed on me and then again as an alcoholic in recovery at the age of 60 at traditional AA meetings and then our secular AA meeting is booted out of Alcoholics Anonymous. My reaction to all of this: God dammit!

When we were booted out of AA in 2011 that is exactly when and why this website was created. The website was active for 11 years – posting a total of 742 articles written by people from around the world – with the last one posted in mid-June 2022. And then after two years, we decided to post articles again! One every week for a year with the first one on June 16th, 2024.

Let me also mention that when AA Agnostica was active, a number of books were published. Here are three of them (more information about each is available on this website):

And why were they published? Well, when I got sober in 2010  there were very few books about recovery from alcoholism that I found helpful. As I mentioned earlier, for me the Big Book has way too much God stuff. I didn’t enjoy reading it, especially the We Agnostics chapter. And that’s why I published a number of books, one of them being The Little Book. It has twenty mostly secular versions of the 12 Steps, four interpretations of each of the Steps – by people like Gabor Maté whose most recent book is The Myth of Normal and Stephanie Covington whose book is A Woman’s Way Through the Twelve Steps – and finally an essay I wrote called The Origins of the 12 Steps.

I also got permission from the authors, Martha and Arlys, to republish The Alternative 12 Steps, which was originally published way back in 1991. It is a very popular book, as it should be.

And I have published two books by my friend, bob k, the fellow who taught me and my wife how to play golf! One of those books is called Key Players in AA History. The first edition was published in 2015 and an updated second edition was published in 2023. It is a very well researched history of the founders and early members of Alcoholics Anonymous.

Okay, let’s get back to the Magical Mystery Tour!

When I am outside I am stunned by what I see. I simply can’t believe that there are so many different trees and flowers. How many kinds of trees are there? There are over 73,000 different kinds of trees! And flowers. How many different flowers? Well, there are over 400,000 different flowers on planet earth! A staggering number that, at the very least, evokes awe.

I also end up staring at the clouds, the sun and, later in the day, the moon. It’s all a part of living on Planet Earth. And there are also the cosmos, the universe and galaxies. As Salwa Salah, a philosopher, put it:

Some estimates suggest that there could be as many as 10 trillion galaxies in the universe, with each galaxy containing billions of stars. It’s an awe-inspiring thought to consider just how vast and incomprehensible the universe really is.

Incomprehensible indeed.

So, finally, this question: what do I think living my life is all about? That’s the question I asked myself way back then, when I was 19 years old and quit believing in a deity. Well, I’m going to be silly and mention my favourite band, The Beatles. Life to me is well described in the name of one of their albums, an album released in November, 1967. It’s a Magical Mystery Tour. Surprisingly I enjoy each and every day. It’s my tour. The magical mystery one. And the title of the last song on the album is “All You Need Is Love.”

I agree. That’s no doubt one of the best parts of the magical mystery tour of life.


For a PDF of this article, click here: The Magical Mystery Tour.


 

16 Responses

  1. Joe C says:

    Ernie Kurtz said recovery is more craft than science, and that applies to many things in life. The mystery is always going to be bigger than that which I understand.

    Like other earthlings, I struggle with uncertainty, search for meaning, and sometimes want answers or guarantees. I still crave these comforts but I am not willing to compromise a shot at clear, curious, thinking or my sense of awe (which would diminish if I knew everything, lol).

    Embracing the uncertainty is part of emotional maturity. It’s popular; I read today in Pew Research that only 40% of Americans consider religion (which offers vague certainty and conditional guarantees) very important in their lives. I see that the younger generation has not adopted a black-and-white view of the world. I try to bring curiosity and positive regard to life’s turns. So often, “Bad Things” have had unintended consequences, and they were not bad at all… Besides, they were inevitable, so why did I spend so much energy on such things? I laugh (at myself).

    Roger, thanks first for being someone I have enjoyed having on the Magical Mystery Tour Bus, and thanks for this retrospective. Peace, brother.

  2. John R says:

    Thanks, Roger. BTW, what also amazes me is that there are supposed to be more neurons in the human brain than there are stars in the universe … it seems unimaginable to me.

  3. Ali H. says:

    Sitting on my deck catching up on daily readings and the essay published today! August 11, 2024. What a wonderful way to start my day. After coming to AA meetings since 1988, I started to slip away. Religious dogma had become a feature of AA meetings. There was no longer pretense of finding a higher power. It became a program of finding god, not a a program of action, soon after, Christian Jesus entered the room. As one who was born and raised atheist with Jewish ethnicity AA welcomed me to find my own path to recovery from the ravages of alcoholism and destructive addictive behaviors. Then suddenly, I no longer belonged. I went down a rabbit hole into the depths of despair. As coined in AA, I became desperate as the dying can be. I was willing to go to any lengths to maintain my sobriety and emotional well being. I found the book Beyond Belief and then the online Zoom meetings. I have found a new freedom and a new happiness with the help of the fellowship in secular AA. I can now use all the ethical principles and the program of action I learned all these years. Thank you for sharing this new essay. I hope to see many more. So many lives will be touched for the better.

  4. Karl A. says:

    A great Sunday morning thought Roger. As an agnostic I find the wonder in everything awe inspiring as well. To me the reflections of a door between two opposing mirrors revealing a peek at infinity, is enough to satisfy my need to look for something that will always be beyond my comprehension. I write this as I watch a mother sparrow feeding her young, indeed a Magical Mystery Tour.

  5. Cathy says:

    Oh Roger – so grateful you got it together – the glue that kept many of us inspired and enthusiastic.

    Welcome back.

    Cathy M 🇨🇦

  6. Hilary J. says:

    Great article, Roger! My higher power is the abundance and diversity of life. Thank you so much for all your service.

  7. Teresa says:

    Yes indeed! Magical mystery journey this life is.
    Thanks Roger! Great getting posts again.
    Teresa in Monterey CA

  8. bob k. says:

    The essay theme reminded me of my California friend ”Aweful Eric”—an atheist who is in awe of his sober life and our amazing universe. W.B. Yeats wrote that the world is full of magical things waiting only for our senses to be sharper. My senses have the chance to be sharper in sobriety but I need to remind myself.

    I relate to the Catholic upbringing. After the full blown indoctrination through nun-led elementary schools and Jesuit high school, I was SHOCKED when one of my University of Toronto professors declared that he was an atheist—and he said that OUT LOUD. Two others OPENLY identified as agnostic. The expected lightning strikes did not come.

    The whole ”sinners going to Hell” thing had seemed dreadfully unfair as puberty taught me that sin was inevitable (if you follow me) I began looking at the whole ”big picture” and by 19 or 20, I tossed out the entire religious/spiritual package. It was a case of contempt AFTER investigation.

    AA’s religiosity was a shocker. Nonetheless, I managed to get sober and stay sober. The members were (mostly) less crazed than the literature.

    Fabulous essay. I may weigh in later on Toronto Intergroup’s 2011 attempt to ”purify” Alcoholics Anonymous. That all led to some unexpected consequences that were both magical and mysterious.

  9. carolyn b says:

    Lovely article. Thanks for sharing. I must look for some secular meetings- been sober since 1989 and still struggle with God, all the God prayers, and the continuous comments that this is not a religious program…..historically speaking, I don’t believe that is true. So happy you are back and I look forward to seeing your posted articles in my inbox.

  10. Wisewebwoman says:

    Thanks so much Roger, you have been instrumental in my embracing my out of the closet atheism in AA. And mighty pleased indeed that it’s becoming far more acceptable out here on the Rock to out oneself and not be condemned to the failure of “lapsing” by the god botherers.I am joined by a few who make our points gently and hang our hats proudly on our multiple decades of sobriety as proof of other ways to achieve long lasting sobriety without getting on our knees or mantras to the Great Invisible Housekeeper.
    Much respect also for your battle with GTA AA. I remember those times and your persistence.

  11. Anonymous says:

    Thanks for your Posting, I’d like to get the three books some time. I’ve been through the A.A. wringer and the religious wringer too.

  12. Bill G says:

    Thanks for your article. I’m happy to see this site up and a chance to share Our experience strength and hope uncensored.

  13. Dan V says:

    Thanks Roger for all that you do to move forward the Secular AA message. I’m still involved because of people like yourself otherwise I would of said “by by” a long time ago ☮️.

  14. Suzie says:

    Interesting article. I’ve been sober a long time (over 37 years) and have often gotten turned off by leanings toward religion in the program. The thing I found interesting is that the groups you mentioned were “booted” out of AA. I live near the birthplace of AA and my understanding of the 12 traditions is that anyone can call themselves an AA group. The “original” (long form) of the second tradition states in part that “any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group, provided that, as a group, they have no other affiliation.” So sad that this happened especially since the big book also mentions that tolerance of others is a part of our recovery.

    • bob k. says:

      The good news is that the exiled groups have been readmitted, partly for the reasons you mention. The intolerance of Toronto Intergroup was ultimately met with some intolerance of the IG by the General Service Office people who pressured the intergroup to readmit the ”agnostic” groups. Larry K. was doing very well in making his case to the adjudicators representing the Province of Ontario. AA and intergroups have to obey the law.

  15. Barbara B. says:

    Nothing brilliant – just a Thank you so much! I’ve been enjoying the articles, comments & humor!

    Please keep them coming. I will also send these to my very non – religious, open minded friends!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Translate »

Discover more from AA Agnostica

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading